C1 Advanced (CAE) - Multiple Matching 4

Four Experts Test Premium Drills

A. Sarah Chen - Testing the Bosch Pro 5000
Having spent two decades renovating properties, I know what I'm looking for in a drill, and this one largely delivers. The brushless motor provides impressive torque control, though it takes some getting used to. At 2.3kg it's not the lightest, but the ergonomic grip compensates somewhat. What really stands out is the intelligent sensor technology that prevents over-drilling - a godsend when working with delicate materials. The battery life is decent, lasting through a full day of heavy use, though the charging time could be better. The LED guide light is well-positioned, unlike some models where your hand casts shadows exactly where you need to see. Price-wise, it's eye-watering, but quality tools are worth the investment. That said, I wish manufacturers would stop adding unnecessary "smart" features - I don't need my drill to connect to my phone, thank you very much. The three-year warranty is reassuring, though I doubt I'll need it given Bosch's reliability record.

B. Mike Peterson - Testing the DeWalt XR Power
Let me be upfront: DIY isn't my favourite pastime, but testing tools is part of the job. This DeWalt model, weighing in at 1.8kg, makes the task less painful than most. The standout feature is the precision clutch with 15 settings, though frankly, who needs that many? The battery charges quickly (about 40 minutes), but you'll need that second battery they include because it drains faster than my bank account after a trip to the hardware store. Build quality is solid, and the chuck has minimal wobble even at high speeds. The carrying case is sturdy, though the internal organisation is puzzling - apparently, DeWalt thinks we all have three hands to arrange tools perfectly. While it's not the most expensive option out there, you're definitely paying extra for the brand name. The included bit set is comprehensive, I'll give them that, though the bits are arranged in size order rather than frequency of use, which is just plain irritating. And don't get me started on the instruction manual - it seems to assume you've got a PhD in engineering and infinite patience.

C. Tom Richards - Testing the Makita LXT Elite
After thirty years in construction, I've developed some strong opinions about tools, and this Makita has both impressed and irritated me in equal measure. The dual-battery system provides phenomenal power, but it also means double the weight at 2.6kg - my arms certainly knew about it after a day of overhead work. The variable speed trigger is beautifully responsive, and the anti-vibration technology actually makes a noticeable difference. However, the position of the reverse switch is plain awkward - I lost count of how many times I accidentally switched it while working. The build quality is exceptional, as you'd expect from Makita, and it handled everything from masonry to delicate cabinet work. The price tag is substantial, but it's built to last - unlike my patience for those promotional videos showing professionals completing projects in unrealistic timeframes. The side handle is well-designed, though attaching it feels like solving a puzzle every time.

D. Rachel Watson - Testing the Milwaukee M18 Fuel
As someone who regularly tests tools for various publications, I've handled my fair share of drills, and this one sits firmly in the "nearly but not quite" category. At 2.1kg, it strikes a reasonable balance between power and weight. The brushless motor delivers impressive torque, though the highest setting is overkill for most tasks - unless you're planning to drill through reinforced concrete for fun. Battery life is adequate, lasting about six hours of intermediate use. The build quality is robust, though the chuck could be smoother. What really grinds my gears is the overcomplicated user manual - I've read easier quantum physics papers. The carry case is well-designed, I'll give them that, though at this price point, you'd expect nothing less. And speaking of price, you might want to sit down before checking that particular detail. The five-year warranty sounds impressive until you read the novel-length list of exclusions. At least the LED work light is bright enough to signal passing aircraft, which might come in handy if you ever need rescuing from an overly ambitious DIY project.